Coldcard CEO Says 0.17% of Users Were Affected as Bitcoin Theft Tops $100M
Coinkite CEO Rodolfo Novak says approximately 0.17% of Coldcard users were affected by a firmware vulnerability linked to more than $100 million in stolen Bitcoin.
By Saloni RathiSenior Editor

More than $100 million in Bitcoin has been stolen from wallets created using vulnerable Coldcard hardware wallet firmware. Coinkite CEO Rodolfo Novak has now said that approximately 0.17% of Coldcard users were affected, but his estimate has drawn criticism as questions about the number of victims and the company's response remain unresolved.
Novak made the comments in response to criticism on X, where users questioned the company's accountability for the losses. He initially described the affected share as around 0.2%, then clarified that it was closer to 0.17%.
The thefts began on July 30, 2026, and were linked to a firmware vulnerability that weakened the randomness used to generate wallet recovery seeds. Galaxy Research has tracked approximately 1,830 BTC stolen from around 9,200 addresses, worth roughly $116 million at the time of its September estimate.
Coinkite CEO Faces Questions Over the 0.17% Figure
Novak said he calculated the 0.17% estimate using loss reports, public blockchain data, and Coinkite's internal production figures.
However, the company has not disclosed its total sales figures or published a verified count of affected customers. There is also a distinction between the number of compromised devices, wallet addresses, and individual users.
One person can own multiple Coldcard devices or control several Bitcoin addresses. As a result, the 0.17% figure cannot yet be independently converted into a confirmed number of affected customers.
The CEO's comments have also attracted criticism from users who questioned the timing and tone of his response. Novak reportedly said he had spent 18 years working on Bitcoin adoption and posted that he planned to take a step back from the industry. He did not clarify whether this meant he intended to leave his position at Coinkite.
Some critics also challenged his response to the backlash after he described certain critical accounts as competitors' bots.
Coinkite has not published a final victim count. Its security status page acknowledges that the public blockchain record does not provide a complete model-by-model ledger of affected users.
How the Coldcard Vulnerability Exposed Bitcoin Wallets
The incident was not caused by attackers remotely accessing Coldcard devices or breaking Bitcoin's blockchain.
Instead, the problem involved how certain devices generated wallet recovery seeds.
A firmware change introduced in March 2021 caused some Coldcard devices to fall back to a weak software-based pseudorandom number generator rather than properly using the hardware random number generator.
A wallet's recovery seed is used to derive its private keys. If the seed is generated with insufficient randomness, attackers may be able to narrow down the possible combinations and recreate the keys using computing power.
That is what made the vulnerability particularly serious. Attackers did not need to physically steal a hardware wallet or obtain its recovery phrase. They could target wallets whose seeds had already been generated under vulnerable conditions.
The first major thefts were reported on July 30, with multiple waves of Bitcoin transfers following over the next several days.
For a detailed breakdown of the affected devices, firmware versions, and how the vulnerability worked, read our earlier report: Everything You Need to Know About the Coldcard Bitcoin Wallet Hack.
Galaxy Research Tracks Around 1,830 BTC in Losses
Galaxy Research has been among the main sources tracking the stolen Bitcoin.
In September, Galaxy's Alex Thorn cited approximately 1,830 BTC stolen from around 9,200 addresses. The estimate was worth roughly $116 million at the time.
The firm had also received reports directly from victims. In one update, 256 victims had contacted Galaxy, including 245 individuals associated with 2,585 addresses holding a combined 895 BTC.
These figures illustrate why the number of affected addresses should not be treated as the number of individual victims. A single person may control multiple addresses, and not every address necessarily represents a separate customer.
The stolen funds have also been traced through several transactions. In September, Galaxy reported that an attacker behind the third wave had moved 97.09 BTC through swaps and CoinJoin transactions. Earlier tracking showed that much of the stolen Bitcoin remained in attacker-controlled addresses.
The full amount may still be subject to revisions as researchers identify additional addresses and connect transactions to the incident.
Firmware Updates Do Not Repair Existing Wallet Seeds
Coldcard has released fixed firmware for the affected device lines. However, installing an update does not make a recovery seed generated under vulnerable firmware safe.
According to Coldcard's current security status page, the fixed releases include:
- Mk2 and Mk3: Version 4.2.0 or later
- Mk4 and Mk5 standard: Version 5.6.0 or later
- Q standard: Version 1.5.0Q or later
- Mk4 and Mk5 Edge: Version 6.6.0X or later
- Q Edge: Version 6.6.0QX or later
The company's latest recommended standard releases are Mk4/Mk5 version 5.6.3 and Q version 1.5.3Q.
Users who generated a seed under affected conditions must follow Coldcard's migration guidance and move their funds to a newly generated seed, unless they qualify for the specific independent-dice exception described in its advisory.
Simply updating the firmware or moving the same recovery phrase to another device does not resolve the original exposure.
Coldcard has also published independent checks of specific remediation mechanisms, including hardware random-number generation and firmware source reviews. However, the company states that these checks do not constitute a complete audit of every firmware binary or guarantee that the devices are free of other defects.
Its security status page continues to serve as the living incident record, while a separate detailed technical postmortem remains in preparation.
Coldcard Theft Raises Questions About Hardware Wallet Security
The incident highlights a distinction that Bitcoin holders sometimes overlook: keeping private keys offline does not automatically make a wallet secure.
Hardware wallets protect keys from many online threats, but their security also depends on how those keys are generated, stored, and used.
In the Coldcard case, the weakness existed at the seed-generation stage. Once an affected recovery seed had been created, the wallet could remain offline while its funds were still vulnerable to an attacker who could recreate the corresponding keys.
The incident also raises questions about how hardware wallet manufacturers communicate vulnerabilities, identify affected customers, and report losses when their products are designed to minimize customer data collection.
With more than $100 million in Bitcoin reportedly stolen and the CEO's 0.17% estimate still unverified, the focus now extends beyond the original firmware bug. Users are also looking for clearer answers about the number of affected customers, the company's remediation efforts, and the final technical findings.

Saloni Rathi
Saloni Rathi has been part of Altcoin Buzz for over five years, working across content and marketing within the crypto and Web3 space. Her work focuses on creating clear, engaging and accessible content that helps readers understand complex cryptocurrency and blockchain topics. With a strong interest in storytelling and audience engagement, Saloni brings together research, creativity and marketing insight to turn complex ideas into simple and relatable stories. She believes great content starts with curiosity, creates clarity, and ultimately builds meaningful connections with readers.
More from SaloniNext up

Lighter Blames Leaked API Key for Reported $15.5M Drain
Lighter blames a leaked API key, not its contracts, for the 16 November incident that halted withdrawals; researchers estimate a $15.5 million loss.
Related
More in Crypto NewsRelated
Zoom, CNN & Ledger Caught in Major Crypto Malware Attack Across 178 Sites

NVIDIA Posts 103% Revenue Growth as AI Crypto Projects Watch GPU Demand

Solana Foundation Acquires Majority Stake in CoinGecko
